Chicken Pot Pie Soup Recipe (Crock Pot) | Wholesome Yum (2024)

You’re going to love this chicken pot pie soup recipe in the Crock Pot! It’s thick, creamy comfort food in a bowl, and has all of the traditional flavors of chicken pot pie and chicken stew, but it won’t weigh you down. Try this slow cooker pot pie soup next time you need an easy and cozy meal.

Recreating classic comfort foods in a healthier ways is sort of a game for me. Is it possible? Will it be just as satisfying? Is it good enough to “trick” my friends and family?

These are the questions that I consider when creating these classics with a healthy twist… like cauliflower baked ziti, keto shepherd’s pie, and lasagna stuffed peppers. I think I found a winner this time!

What Is Chicken Pot Pie Soup?

Slow cooker chicken pot pie soup is essentially a chicken pot pie without the crust, made in your Crock Pot! It takes all of the flavor of the pot pie filling and is served up as a soup.

Ingredients For Chicken Pot Pie Soup

This recipe for homemade chicken pot pie soup comes together with simple ingredients:

• Butter
• Onions – Any kind you like will do
• Chicken breasts – I prefer this pasture raised brand
• Poultry seasoning – I like to make homemade poultry seasoning, but you could also buy it here. Make sure it’s salt-free, as we are already adding salt separately in this pot pie soup recipe.
• Sea salt &black pepper
• Chicken broth – I used low sodium store-bought, but my chicken broth recipe is super easy to make or use any type you prefer just adjust the salt as needed.
• Bay leaf
• Frozen peas and carrots
• Plain cream cheese
• Xanthan gum – Optional, but recommended to thicken the soup

How To Make Chicken Pot Pie Soup In A Crock Pot

• Saute onions. This is an optional, but recommended step. Saute butter and onion in a medium skillet until soft and starting to brown. (This doesn’t take as long as caramelizing onions, though you certainly could if you’re a fan of those!)

• Slow cook the soup. Place chicken breasts in slow cooker and season with poultry seasoning, salt, and pepper. Top with sauteed onion, chicken broth, and bay leaf and cook on low heat in Crock Pot until chicken is cooked through. Remove bay leaf and chicken breasts.

• Shred chicken. Take the chicken out of the slow cooker, shred, and set aside.

• Make it creamy. Heat cream cheese in a medium bowl until soft and place into blender. Working quickly, ladle a cup of broth into blender and blend until smooth. Add more broth and blend again. It should be a smooth liquid. If it’s thick, add more broth and if it’s chunky, keep blending. Sprinkle xanthan gum into blender and blend again. It will start to thicken.

• Cook peas and carrots. Turn the slow cooker to high heat and add frozen peas and carrots. They’ll cook pretty quickly, about 15 minutes or so.

• Assemble. Whisk in cream cheese mixture to soup until smooth. Add shredded chicken and adjust salt if needed.

Chicken Pot Pie Soup Recipe FAQs

Is chicken pot pie soup healthy?

Yes, this thick and creamy soup is surprisingly light and healthy without tasting like it.

Is chicken pot pie soup keto?

Yes, this chicken pot pie is suitable for a low carb diet, as each serving (1 cup) has just 8.6 grams net carbs.

Many other pot pie soup recipes are thickened with flour and usually topped with a biscuit or pie crust, which would make them not keto-friendly.

How to thicken chicken pot pie soup?

Some recipes use a flour roux to thicken them, but I prefer a grain-free, low carb option. We are thickening it with a combination of cream cheese and xanthan gum instead.

Can I make creamy chicken soup dairy-free?

Yes, you can make this dairy-free if you swap the butter and cream cheese for your favorite dairy-free alternatives.

Slow Cooker Pot Pie Soup Storage Instructions

Can you make it ahead?

Yes, you can make this easy pot pie soup ahead. Soup is the ultimate meal prep dish and reheats well.

How to store leftovers:

If you have homemade chicken pot pie soup left over, store it in the refrigerator for 3-5 days.

Can chicken pot pie soup be frozen?

Yes, you can freeze the soup for 2-3 months. Cream-based soups do run some risk of separating when thawed, but you can usually just bring it back together when reheating.

Reheating instructions:

Reheat the soup in a saucepan on the stove over medium heat, until hot. To prevent separation, stir frequently and do not boil.

What To Serve With Chicken Pot Pie Soup

• Salads – Soup and salad is the perfect match! Top your fave greens with Italian dressing, creamy balsamic, or ranch.
• Healthy breads – Healthy bread recipes such as almond flour biscuits, 90-second bread, or keto white bread mix all pair well with the best chicken pot pie soup.
• Crackers – Cracker recipes like almond flour crackers, keto cheese crackers, or coconut flour crackers are an easy addition for healthy creamy soups like this one.

More Healthy Soup Recipes

If you like this creamy chicken pot pie soup recipe, you might also like some of these other healthy soup recipes:

• Broccoli Cheddar Soup – The BEST broccoli cheddar soup made with just 5 ingredients and made in 20 minutes.
• Stuffed Pepper Soup – A cozy one-pot meal that’s ready in 30 minutes. Packed with veggies and flavor.
• Whole30 Chili – This wholesome chili is made with simple ingredients and is a satisfying meal in a bowl.
• Roasted Poblano Chicken Soup – To keep it low carb, swap cauliflower for the potatoes and omit the corn.
• Italian Sausage Kale Soup – Flavorful sausage, a creamy broth, and plenty of kale. Ready in 30 minutes.

• Crock Pot – If you want homemade chicken pot pie soup in a Crock Pot, you need… well, a Crock Pot! 😉 I’ve owned a few and this one is my favorite, because it can be programmed at 30-minute intervals and automatically switches over to the Warm function once the cooking time runs out.
• Blender – The best blender. I use it for everything from keto green smoothies to blending soups like this one.